Goodbye 2nd amendment

[dxoigmn]

Well in that case, what anti-constitutional argument is there?

Our second amendment gives us the right to bear arms. Proposition H in San Francisco impedes on the second amendment.

Yeah if you conveniently ignore the first 13 words!

@ CrAz3d: You taking the pretty liberal interpretation of the Constitution with your stance. I thought the Constitution was not a living document, but meant to be strictly interpreted?

[Invert]

Well in that case, what anti-constitutional argument is there?

Our second amendment gives us the right to bear arms. Proposition H in San Francisco impedes on the second amendment.

Yeah if you conveniently ignore the first 13 words!

There is a comma after the 1st 13 words. The 1st part allows us to assemble a regulated militia if need be for the protection of freedom and the 2nd part allows us to bear arms.

[Arta]

Our second amendment gives us the right to bear arms. Proposition H in San Francisco impedes on the second amendment.

I'm not sure about that. Read the rest of my posts in this thead.

Say the city banned free speech, is that unconstitutional?

I don't know. That's why I don't understand Grok's point fully.

[Invert]

Our second amendment gives us the right to bear arms. Proposition H in San Francisco impedes on the second amendment.

I'm not sure about that. Read the rest of my posts in this thead.

Say the city banned free speech, is that unconstitutional?

I don't know. That's why I don't understand Grok's point fully.

Arta if you don't know the answer to that question you are ignorant on this whole entire matter and should not participate in this discussion.

[Arta]

Well, I would have thought there is a good argument (an unassailably iron-clad one, in fact) for banning free speech being unconstitutional, but then I read Grok's posts, which seem to indicate that it might not be. Thus, I am now confused. I'm quite sure I've just misunderstood Grok's point.

[CrAz3D]

Well in that case, what anti-constitutional argument is there?

Our second amendment gives us the right to bear arms. Proposition H in San Francisco impedes on the second amendment.

Yeah if you conveniently ignore the first 13 words!

@ CrAz3d: You taking the pretty liberal interpretation of the Constitution with your stance. I thought the Constitution was not a living document, but meant to be strictly interpreted?

What do ya mean?...